Think of this as a marketing playbook you can run every week.
When a real estate agent asks me about marketing, the question is usually about new leads. Should I buy Zillow leads? Run Facebook ads? Post more reels?
Those can all work. But before we talk about any of them, I ask one question: how many people in your phone have bought or sold a home with you, and when did you last talk to each of them?
The answer tells me more about an agent’s next twelve months than any ad budget.
Where buyers and sellers actually find their agent
The National Association of REALTORS publishes a yearly Profile of Home Buyers and Sellers. Virginia REALTORS summarized the 2025 edition, which surveyed people who bought or sold between July 2024 and June 2025. A few numbers stood out to me:
- 88% of buyers purchased through an agent or broker.
- 43% of buyers used an agent they found through a referral, and another 18% went back to an agent they had worked with before.
- 66% of sellers found their agent through a referral or used an agent they had worked with in the past.
Read that again. For sellers, the people who bring listings, about two out of three picked someone they already knew or someone a friend sent them to.
That doesn’t mean ads are useless. It means the biggest source of business for most agents is a list of people they already have and probably aren’t working.
Step 1: Get your database out of your head
Most agents I talk to have their past clients spread across a phone, an old brokerage CRM, a spreadsheet from three years ago, and a closing gift list in a notes app. That’s not a database. That’s a scavenger hunt.
Pick one place. It can be a real CRM or, for now, one clean spreadsheet. Put everyone in it:
- Past buyers and sellers, with closing dates and addresses
- Friends, family, church, kids’ sports, old coworkers, anyone who knows what you do
- Other professionals who send business: lenders, title officers, builders, insurance agents, contractors
- Open house sign-ins and online leads that never went anywhere
Then tag each person. A simple A, B, C works. A means they’ve sent you business or would. B means they know you and like you. C means they barely remember you.
If you’re wondering whether you’ve outgrown the spreadsheet, I wrote about that in Do You Need a CRM? 7 Signs Your Business Has Outgrown the Spreadsheet.
Step 2: Stay in touch on a schedule, not a mood
The agents who get referrals aren’t always the best negotiators. They’re the ones people remember when a coworker says, “We’re thinking about selling.”
Being remembered takes a rhythm. Here’s a simple one:
Monthly, for everyone
One useful email or text a month. Not a newsletter full of stock photos. Something a homeowner would actually want: what homes sold for in their neighborhood, a reminder to check the roof after a storm, a property tax protest deadline, a trusted plumber’s name.
Quarterly, for your A and B lists
A personal touch. A phone call, a handwritten note, a coffee. Ask about their kids, their job, their house. Don’t ask for a referral every time. Ask maybe once a year, plainly: “If you hear of anyone thinking about buying or selling, I’d love to help them.”
Yearly, for past clients
A home anniversary message on their closing date. It costs nothing, it’s personal, and it’s one of the easiest things to automate once your closing dates are in one place.
Step 3: Use local moments as a reason to reach out
West Texas gives you plenty of natural reasons to call that aren’t a sales pitch.
- Hail season. After a big storm, check in with past clients in the affected area. Do they need a roofer or an adjuster recommendation? You’ll be the helpful person, not the agent asking for business.
- Property tax season. In Texas, appraisal notices go out in the spring. A short note explaining how to look up their value and the protest deadline is about as useful as content gets.
- Summer heat. A reminder to service the A/C before July, with the name of an HVAC company you trust.
- Back to school and Tech’s calendar. Families moving for school zones and people relocating to Lubbock for work or Texas Tech tend to follow the calendar. Plan your outreach around it.
Each of these makes you useful between transactions, which is when the referral decision actually happens.
Step 4: Respond fast to the leads you do get
Referrals come in warm, but they still go cold if nobody answers. A friend texts your number to their brother-in-law, he calls on a Saturday afternoon while you’re at a showing, and he calls the next agent on his list.
A few simple fixes:
- Turn on missed-call text-back so nobody hits a dead voicemail.
- Reply to every online inquiry within minutes during business hours, even if it’s just “Got it, I’ll call you at 4.”
- Have a short intake script: name, timeline, buying or selling, pre-approved or not, best time to talk.
I covered the why behind this in Speed to Lead: Why Lubbock Businesses Lose Jobs in the First Hour.
Step 5: Show up where people check you out
Even a referral will look you up before calling. They’ll search your name, look at your Google Business Profile and reviews, and maybe ask ChatGPT or Google’s AI who the good agents are in their part of town.
Make sure they find:
- A Google Business Profile with your real photo, the areas you serve, and recent reviews
- A simple page or profile that says who you help (first-time buyers, relocations, farm and ranch, new construction) and how to reach you
- Reviews that mention specific neighborhoods and situations, which you get by asking right after closing, while the good feeling is fresh
Step 6: Then add paid leads, carefully
Once your database is clean, your follow-up runs on a schedule, and your phone gets answered, paid leads make a lot more sense. Now every lead you buy goes into a system that actually works it, instead of a pile you’ll get to later.
Track where every closing came from. If you can’t tell whether your last ten deals came from referrals, past clients or paid leads, you can’t tell which marketing is paying for itself.
What to do this week
- Export every contact you have from every place they live and put them in one list.
- Tag the top 50 as A or B.
- Call five past clients just to check in. No pitch.
- Put closing dates on the calendar for home anniversary messages.
- Write one useful local message, maybe on property taxes or winter prep, and send it to your whole list.
None of this is flashy. But it’s how agents build a business that doesn’t start from zero every January.
Want help turning your contact list into a system that brings back repeat and referral business? Our MarketTap Blueprint maps your lead sources, follow-up and marketing spend into a prioritized 90-day plan. Or book a strategy call and we’ll look at where your last ten closings came from, together.