When a dental practice owner tells me the schedule has too many holes, the conversation usually starts with ads. Should we run more Google ads? Try Facebook? Hire an agency?
Sometimes the answer is yes. But in my experience, most open chairs come from somewhere less exciting: a phone that goes to voicemail at lunch, a review profile that hasn’t seen a new review since spring, and a recall list nobody has worked in months.
Here’s the playbook I’d use for a practice in Lubbock or anywhere in West Texas, in order.
Why this matters right now
The American Dental Association’s Health Policy Institute tracks how practices are doing. ADA News, reporting on HPI data from the fourth quarter of 2025, said one-third of dentists reported insufficient patient volume. The same report said more than one-third of dentists plan to drop some dental insurance networks in 2026.
That second number is the one I’d pay attention to. If you leave a network, some of the patients who found you through that insurer’s directory will stop finding you. Your own marketing has to pick up that slack. That’s a lot easier if the basics are already working.
Step 1: Win the search before you buy one
Most new patients start the same way: they search on their phone, look at the map results, and tap the practice that looks trustworthy and close.
Your Google Business Profile
For a lot of patients, your Google Business Profile is the first impression, not your website. Make sure it shows:
- The right primary category, plus secondary categories for what you actually offer
- Every service you want to be found for: cleanings, crowns, implants, emergency visits, Invisalign or other aligners, pediatric care
- Current hours, including lunch closures and holiday changes
- Real photos of your office, your team and your front door, so a nervous patient knows what they’re walking into
- Which insurance plans you accept, kept current, especially if you’re leaving a network
I wrote more about this in Your Google Business Profile Is Your Real Homepage. For a dental office, it’s especially true.
Your website’s service pages
Each core service deserves its own page that answers the questions patients ask on the phone: Do you take my insurance? What does it cost without insurance? Does it hurt? How long does it take? Do you see kids? Can I get in this week?
Plain answers help patients decide and give Google and AI tools something specific to work with.
Step 2: Reviews are your waiting room
Patients read reviews before they pick a dentist, and they look at how recent they are. BrightLocal’s 2026 Local Consumer Review Survey, published in February and based on 1,002 U.S. consumers, found that 74% look for reviews written in the last three months. It also found that 89% expect business owners to respond to reviews, and 42% are unlikely to use a business that never replies.
So a practice with 300 reviews from 2022 and nothing since can lose to a newer practice with 60 reviews from this fall.
Build reviews into the visit
Don’t rely on a quarterly email blast. Make the ask part of checkout:
- The hygienist or dentist mentions it at the end of a good visit.
- The front desk sends one text with a direct link to your Google review page before the patient reaches their car.
- That’s it. One ask, no repeated nagging.
Reply carefully
Reply to every review, but be careful what you say. A dental office has privacy rules a roofer doesn’t. A good default is a short, warm reply that thanks them without confirming they’re a patient or mentioning any treatment. For negative reviews, invite them to call the office directly. I’m not a lawyer, so have your compliance advisor sign off on a few standard replies your team can use.
Step 3: Answer the phone like it’s the front door
For most practices, the phone is still where new patients become appointments. And it rings at the worst times: during checkout, during lunch, right after 5.
Do this test this week: call your own office at 12:15 p.m. and again at 5:30 p.m. from a number they won’t recognize. Note what happens. If it goes to a full voicemail box or a recording that just lists your hours, that’s a patient calling the next office on the list.
A few fixes, from cheapest to most involved:
- Missed-call text-back. When nobody can pick up, the caller gets a text within seconds offering to help. I covered it in Missed-Call Text-Back: The Cheapest Fix in Local Marketing.
- Online booking for new patients. Even if it’s limited to new-patient exams and cleanings, it catches the people searching at 10 p.m.
- Overflow help. An answering service or a carefully set-up AI receptionist can cover lunch and after-hours, as long as it hands anything clinical or urgent to a person.
- A simple phone script. Greet, get the caller’s name, ask what they need, ask about insurance, offer two specific times. New front-desk hires can learn it on day one.
Step 4: Work the patients you already have
New-patient marketing gets all the attention, but your existing patient list is usually the fastest way to fill a schedule.
Recall and reactivation
Pull a list of patients who are overdue for a cleaning, sorted by how long it’s been. Then:
- Send a friendly text from the office number, not a generic blast: “Hi Maria, this is Jen at Dr. Smith’s office. It looks like you’re due for a cleaning. Want us to find you a time?”
- Follow up with a call a week later for the ones who don’t respond.
- Note who has moved, switched dentists or asked not to be contacted, and clean the list as you go.
Unscheduled treatment
Every practice has patients who were told they need a crown or other treatment and never scheduled it. A short, polite follow-up sequence (a check-in after a few days, another after two weeks, a reminder before their insurance benefits reset) brings back more of them than you’d expect. Just keep the messages about scheduling, not clinical details.
Year-end benefits
If a patient’s plan runs on the calendar year, November and December are their last chance to use this year’s benefits. A reminder that their benefits may reset in January is helpful, not pushy, and it fits naturally into recall.
Step 5: Spend on ads only after the leaks are fixed
Once your profile, reviews, phones and recall are in shape, paid ads make a lot more sense. Point them at specific, high-value services you want more of, like implants, emergency visits or new-patient exams, and send them to a page about that service, not your homepage.
Track every call and booking back to where it came from. If you can’t tell which patients came from ads, you can’t tell if the ads work.
Step 6: Get known around town
School presentations, youth sports sponsorships, health fairs and referral relationships with pediatricians or orthodontists put your name in front of families before they need you. They also create independent mentions that help with local search and AI answers.
What to do this week
- Call your own office at lunch and after 5. Write down what happens.
- Check your Google Business Profile for hours, services, photos and accepted insurance.
- Count your Google reviews from the last 90 days. If it’s fewer than a handful, start asking at checkout tomorrow.
- Pull your overdue recall list and have someone text the first 25 patients by hand.
- Write three approved review replies with your compliance advisor so your team never has to improvise.
None of this is glamorous. But it keeps chairs full whether or not you’re in every network, and it makes every ad dollar after it work harder.
Want a clear plan for your practice? Our MarketTap Blueprint reviews your search presence, reviews, phones, follow-up and marketing spend and turns it into a prioritized 90-day plan. Or book a strategy call and we’ll walk through where your new patients are coming from, together.